How does Israel benefit from its continued association with American Jewish organizations that are mainstreaming anti-Semitism by minimizing it, and arguing that people who hate Israel are not anti-Semites?
Case in point: The Anti-Defamation League’s “Is Delegitimization of Israel Anti-Semitism?” panel provided well known anti-Zionists Jill Jacobs and Jane Eisner a platform to launch into tirades about evil Israel. In addition, Jacobs defended the BDS movement against accusations of anti-Semitism and criticized the American Jewish community for backing anti-BDS legislation. The ADL-sponsored event also gave free rein to the vilification of such staunch Israel supporters as former Breitbart News CEO Stephen Bannon and Center for Security president Frank Gaffney.
At this point, there’s little to connect the Jewish state to ostensibly centrist American Jewish groups other than mystic cords of memory. The worm has turned, and long gone are the days when such organizations served to bolster Jewish sovereignty by way of a common, non-partisan commitment to the Zionist enterprise.
In recent years, Israel, far from unifying American Jews around a single cause, has actually been the primary source of friction among the Orthodox, Secular, Reform, and Haredi communities in the United States. As a result, donations to Israel are no longer guided by the desire to help the country’s poor, hungry, or otherwise afflicted. Neither is the wish to contribute to a strong Israeli defense posture a primary motivation.
Today, it’s all about politics. American Jewish organizations have morphed into appendages of one of the country’s two main political parties. And with 70% of American Jews voting for Hillary Clinton in the presidential election, the vast majority of American Jewish groups take their marching orders on issues related to Israel from the Democratic Party’s platform and leaders.
Clinton’s loss has catalyzed the Democratic Party’s turning against the Jewish state. Notably, Minnesota congressman Keith Ellison, the front-runner to be the next Democratic National Committee chairman, has a long history of anti-Israel, anti-Semitic, and extremist radical Islamist involvements and positions.
Tellingly, the aforementioned and always vocal Anti-Defamation League suddenly went mute with regard to Ellison’s defamatory remarks and controversial record with regard to Israel. But facts are stubborn things: in 2014, Ellison was one of only eight members of Congress to vote against a bipartisan bill to provide $225 million to Israel’s Iron Dome missile system.
And let’s not even talk about the good Keith X. Ellison’s ties to the Jew-baiting Nation of Islam.
Here’s a fast, harsh dose of reality: the vast majority of politically minded American Jews are passionate about gay marriage, the Paris climate agreement, abortion rights, raising the minimum wage, and other standard talking points from the Progressive playbook. Assimilation and intermarriage have spawned an American Jewish community that’s increasingly disconnected from Israel. Malcolm Hoenlein, now in his 31st year as executive vice chairman of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, has called this the “negative phenomenon of indifference.”
As such, American Jewish groups should embrace this reality and refocus their energies on domestic issues that large swaths of the American Jewish community care about.
Out with supporting Iron Dome; in with dismantling structural racism.
As for Israel, while breaking up is hard to do, disassociating from American Jewish organizations with political agendas will deny the latter the megaphone they’ve been using to lambast the former every time Israeli policy strays from an increasingly hostile Democratic Party line.
I think it’s safe to say that Israel, which The World Economic Forum’s 2016-2017 Global Competitiveness Report recently ranked as the second most innovative nation one earth, will figure out a way to move on.
Read other pieces by Gidon Ben-Zvi that have appeared in American Thinker here.
2 thoughts on “Why Israel has no use for American Jewish organizations”
good job, Gidon. but one problem is that the only so-called major Jewish organization which publicly opposed the ADL is the ZOA– which despite its name and the fact that it was founded way back when by Louis Brandeis has been the fiefdom of Mort Klein for decades. He never delegates, he holds all the cards like a petty tyrant, there is no ZOA branch office anywhere.
Smaller organizations do chip away at the outsized, moneyed influence of the ADL and AJC– CAMERA, honest reporting, americans for truth and justice, stand with us, david horowitz’s frontpagemag.com, etc. but all in all, liberal democrat jews rule the roost and the media.
is this a good time for jews to quit the galus, say goodbye to all that (a line from Robert Graves) and finally make aliyah– or is it a good time to stand, organize and fight back on American soil against all the half-breed jews of the NYT, ADL, et, etc.? it’s an open question with no clear, decisive answer.
Pinchas Baram, Brookline, Mass. firstname.lastname@example.org
You are absolutely correct. Israel has to move on from American Jewish organizations.
But the only support Israeli social service organizations receive from American Jews is from Orthodox Jews and Evangelical Christians
Orthodox Jews visit Israel in greater numbers then any other Denomination